Payroll Compliance: What Employers Keep Getting Wrong

Payroll looks like an HR task. It is four regulators on four calendars, and the errors compound quietly.

Payroll is the compliance area where small errors survive longest. A wrong provident fund calculation on one salary component, repeated monthly across thirty employees, is not discovered by anyone until an inspection or a resignation. By then it is three years of arrears, with interest and damages, for an employer who believed payroll was running fine.

The reason is structural. Payroll looks like a single monthly task, and it is actually four separate regimes with four different bases of calculation.

The four regimes

Regime Broadly covers Owned by
Provident fund Retirement contributions by employee and employer Employer
State insurance Medical and related benefits for lower paid employees Employer
Professional tax A state level levy on employment, where the state has one Employer
Income tax withholding Tax deducted from salary each month Employer

Each has its own definition of what counts as wages, its own coverage test and its own filing calendar. An employee can be inside one and outside another in the same month.

The errors that cost real money

Splitting salary to reduce contributions. Restructuring a salary into allowances to shrink the contribution base is the most frequently attempted saving and the most frequently reversed. What counts as wages for contribution purposes has been the subject of significant decisions, and a structure built on an old understanding is an arrears liability waiting to be found.

Treating contractors as outside payroll. A worker described as a consultant, but working fixed hours under supervision at your premises, may be an employee in substance. The label on the invoice does not settle it. Where contract labour is engaged through an agency, the principal employer also carries responsibility for the agency's compliance.

Missing a new joiner's first month. Coverage attaches from the date of joining, not from the month payroll remembers. Late enrolment of a new employee means arrears for the gap.

Withholding salary tax on an annual estimate that is never revised. Tax on salary is deducted monthly against an estimate of the year's income and the employee's declared investments. Employers who do not collect proofs and revise the estimate under-deduct for most of the year and then have to catch up in the final months, which employees experience as a sudden pay cut.

Deducting but depositing late. The deduction was right and the deposit slipped past the due date. Interest runs automatically, and it is the kind of default that an audit reports.

The monthly discipline

Timing Action
At joining Enrol the employee in every regime they are covered by
Each month Compute contributions on the correct wage base
Each month Deposit within the due date for that regime
Each month Deduct salary tax against a current year estimate
Each quarter File the withholding return and issue the certificates
Each year Collect investment proofs and revise estimates before the final quarter
At exit Settle dues, including gratuity where applicable, and file the exit paperwork

Gratuity and leave are liabilities, not surprises

Gratuity becomes payable on exit after a qualifying period of service, and accrues from the first day of employment. A growing company that has never provided for it in its accounts is understating its liabilities, which matters for its auditors and for anyone doing due diligence on it.

Item Where it should appear
Gratuity accrued Provided in the accounts, actuarially where material
Leave encashment accrued Provided in the accounts
Bonus payable Provided, where the statute applies
Notice period recoveries Documented in the employment contract

What an inspection asks for

  • Register of employees with dates of joining and exit
  • Wage registers, month by month
  • Proof of deposit for every regime, every month
  • Returns filed, with acknowledgements
  • Contracts for every worker, including consultants and agency staff
  • Agency compliance proof, where labour is contracted
  • Investment proofs collected from employees

Most employers can produce the deposits and the returns. Fewer can produce consistent contracts for consultants, and fewer still can produce compliance proof for agency staff.

The case for separating payroll from HR

HR knows what each person should be paid. Compliance knows what the law requires to be withheld, contributed, deposited and filed. Those are different skills, and a small company that asks one person to do both usually gets accurate salaries and inaccurate compliance, because salary errors are noticed within a day and compliance errors within three years.

Talk to us about your payroll

We run payroll compliance for employers across Gurgaon, Delhi and the NCR, and we also conduct one off reviews for companies that want to know where they stand before an inspection or a funding round. A review of three months of payroll usually tells you everything about the other three years.

Wage bases, coverage limits and due dates all change by regime and by state. Ask us for the position applicable to your headcount and your state rather than relying on a general figure.

Want your payroll compliance checked?

Send us three months of payroll and the list of people you engage as consultants. We will tell you where the exposure is and what it would cost to fix.

WhatsApp Our Team

Call or WhatsApp +91 98105 55783, or email caashishemail@gmail.com. Offices in Gurgaon and Delhi.

SKAA & Associates

Chartered Accountants in Gurgaon since 1994. Specializing in statutory audits, income tax advisory, international taxation, transfer pricing, GST compliance, and company registration. A 2nd generation CA firm trusted by 1000+ clients.

Chat with us