An NRI selling a flat in Gurgaon runs into a structural problem that a resident seller does not. Where the seller is a non-resident, the buyer's duty to deduct tax is calculated by reference to the sale consideration, not by reference to the gain. On a property bought twenty years ago and sold at several times the cost, that is still manageable. On a property sold at a modest gain, or at a loss, the amount withheld can dwarf the tax actually payable.
The money is not lost. It is refundable when you file your return. But it is locked up for the better part of a year, and it is usually the whole reason the sale feels punitive.
There is a proper route out of this, and it has to be used before the sale, not after.
Why the default is so heavy
| Resident seller | Non-resident seller | |
|---|---|---|
| Deduction calculated on | A flat rate on the consideration | The seller's income position |
| Practical effect | Modest, predictable | Can greatly exceed the actual tax |
| Buyer needs a TAN | Generally no | Yes |
| Seller's remedy | Claim credit in the return | Lower deduction certificate, in advance |
| Timing of the remedy | After the year | Before the sale |
The lower deduction certificate
The remedy is to apply to the income tax department, before the transaction, for a certificate authorising deduction at a lower rate that reflects your actual expected gain. With the certificate in hand, the buyer deducts the lower amount and your money is not tied up.
| Step | What it involves |
|---|---|
| Establish the cost base | Purchase documents, improvement costs, transfer expenses |
| Compute the expected gain | Including indexation where it is available to you |
| Apply online | In the prescribed form, with documents |
| Respond to queries | The officer may ask for clarification |
| Receive the certificate | Specifying the rate and the buyer |
| Give it to the buyer | They deduct per the certificate |
The application takes time, sometimes a considerable amount of it, and that time has to be built into the transaction timetable. An NRI who signs an agreement to sell with a short completion window and applies afterwards will miss it.
The cost base is where the money is
The gain depends on what you are allowed to deduct from the sale price. Most sellers understate their own cost base because the records are old and scattered across countries.
- The original purchase price, with the registered deed
- Stamp duty and registration paid on purchase
- Cost of improvements, with invoices, not estimates
- Brokerage on the sale
- Legal and documentation costs on the sale
- Where the property was inherited, the cost to the previous owner and the date they acquired it
The inherited property case is worth stating separately because it is counter-intuitive and valuable: the relevant cost and holding period generally relate back to the previous owner, not to the date of inheritance. Sellers who assume their cost is nil pay tax they do not owe.
Whether indexation is available, and on what basis, has been the subject of change. Ask us for the position applicable to your acquisition date and sale date rather than relying on what was true a few years ago.
Repatriation is a separate question
Getting the sale proceeds out of India is governed by the foreign exchange rules, not the tax rules, and the two are often confused.
| Aspect | Position |
|---|---|
| Which account the proceeds go to | Generally your NRO account |
| Annual limit on repatriation from NRO | A prescribed ceiling applies |
| Documentation needed | Accountant's certificate and the prescribed forms |
| Does paying tax guarantee repatriation | No, the exchange control conditions are separate |
| Number of properties | Limits can apply to residential property proceeds |
Plan the repatriation before the sale as well. A seller who needs the entire proceeds abroad in one movement should know the ceiling before agreeing a price and a timetable.
The sequence that works
- Gather the cost documents, including the previous owner's if inherited.
- Compute the expected gain and the tax actually payable.
- Apply for the lower deduction certificate, early.
- Agree the sale with a completion timetable that allows for the certificate.
- Give the certificate to the buyer; confirm they have a TAN.
- Confirm the buyer has deducted and deposited correctly, and collect the certificate.
- File your Indian return for the year and claim credit or refund.
- Complete the repatriation paperwork within the applicable limit.
If you have already sold without the certificate
You are not stuck, you are simply waiting. The excess deducted is recovered by filing your Indian return for that year, and the refund follows. The practical advice is to file early rather than at the deadline, and to make sure the buyer actually deposited what they deducted, because your credit depends on their compliance rather than on your payment.
Talk to us before you sign the agreement to sell
Almost all of the value in this work is in the timing. We act for NRI clients across the Gulf, the United Kingdom, the United States and Singapore on Indian property sales, from the certificate application through to repatriation, working from our Gurgaon and Delhi offices.
Selling property in India as an NRI?
Send us the purchase documents, the expected sale price and your timetable. We will compute the real tax and apply for the lower deduction certificate.
WhatsApp Our TeamCall or WhatsApp +91 98105 55783, or email caashishemail@gmail.com. Offices in Gurgaon and Delhi.