Seven Questions to Ask Before You Appoint a CA Firm

Most businesses pick an accountant on price and regret it at the first notice. Here is what to ask instead.

Most businesses choose a chartered accountant the way they choose a courier: whoever quotes least and answers the phone. That works until the first assessment notice, the first funding due diligence, or the first time a bank asks for three years of clean accounts. Then the difference between a filing shop and an advisory firm becomes very expensive.

If you are appointing a CA firm in Gurgaon, Delhi or anywhere in the NCR, these are the seven questions worth asking before you sign anything.

1. Who will actually do my work?

Ask for a name, not a firm. In many practices the partner wins the client and an articled assistant does the work, with no review in between. That is not automatically wrong, but you should know who is drafting your submissions and who is reading them before they go out.

A good answer names the person handling day to day work, the person reviewing it, and the partner who signs. If you only ever hear one name, ask who covers that person during the filing season.

2. What happens when a notice arrives?

This is the question that reveals everything. Compliance is routine; a notice is not. Find out whether representation is included in the fee or billed separately, how quickly the firm responds, and whether they have handled your kind of matter before.

What you ask A weak answer A strong answer
Who replies to notices? "We will see when it comes." A named person, with a drafting and review step
Is it in the fee? Vague Stated clearly in writing, either way
Have you done this before? "We handle everything." Specific experience, specific forum
Turnaround No commitment A working-day commitment

3. Do you work on the law as it is today?

Indian tax law has just gone through its biggest rewrite in sixty years. The Income-tax Act, 2025 came into force on 1 April 2026 and replaced the Income-tax Act, 1961, with the older law continuing to govern earlier years and pending matters. GST has had its own rounds of restructuring.

A firm that still quotes you section numbers from memory, without checking which Act governs your year, is a firm that will eventually quote you the wrong one. Ask how they keep current and who in the team is responsible for it.

4. How will my records be kept, and can I see them?

You should have access to your own books without asking permission. Ask which accounting software is used, who holds the login, where backups live, and what happens to the data if you change advisers. Firms that treat your ledger as their property are the hardest to leave.

5. What is not included?

Fee disputes almost always come from the gap between what you assumed and what was quoted. Get the boundary in writing.

Usually included Usually extra Always ask
Routine return filing Assessment representation Appeals and litigation
Monthly bookkeeping Certification and attestations Transaction advisory
Statutory audit, if appointed Valuation reports Secretarial and ROC work
Standing compliance calendar Restatement of old years Out of pocket and filing fees

6. Who else do you act for, and is that a problem?

Conflicts are normal in a small professional market and are usually manageable, but they should be disclosed. If your auditor also advises your largest competitor, or your own group company, you want to know before it matters rather than after.

7. Will you tell me when the answer is no?

The most valuable thing a CA firm does is refuse. A firm that agrees to every structure you propose, signs whatever is put in front of it and never pushes back is not protecting you; it is transferring risk to you quietly. Ask directly for an example of advice they have given that a client did not want to hear.

Red flags that are worth walking away from

  • A fee quoted before anyone has looked at your volumes or your history
  • A promise about a refund amount or an assessment outcome
  • Unwillingness to put the scope of work in writing
  • No one in the team who has seen your industry before
  • Reluctance to let you speak to an existing client

What this looks like in practice

Stage What a serious firm does What you should receive
Before appointment Reviews last two years of filings A written scope and fee
First month Builds a compliance calendar for you Dated list of your obligations
Each period Files, then reports what was filed Acknowledgements, not assurances
On a notice Drafts, reviews, represents Copy of everything submitted
Year end Closes books, flags exposures A short list of what to fix

Talk to us before you decide

SKAA & Associates has advised businesses, promoters and families from Gurgaon and Delhi since 1994, across audit, income tax, GST, company law and cross-border matters. We are happy to be asked all seven of these questions, and we would rather you asked them of us than skipped them with someone else.

Rates, thresholds and due dates change, and the one that is right for another business may be wrong for yours. Send us your position and we will tell you where you actually stand.

Looking for a CA firm in Gurgaon or Delhi?

Tell us what your business does and what is worrying you. We will come back with a clear scope, a written fee and an honest view of whether we are the right fit.

WhatsApp Our Team

Call or WhatsApp +91 98105 55783, or email caashishemail@gmail.com. Offices in Gurgaon and Delhi.

SKAA & Associates

Chartered Accountants in Gurgaon since 1994. Specializing in statutory audits, income tax advisory, international taxation, transfer pricing, GST compliance, and company registration. A 2nd generation CA firm trusted by 1000+ clients.

Chat with us